by Paul Peck, Buffalo Sports Page

Big arm.  Check.

Big body.  Check.

Comparisons to Cam Newton & Ben Roethlisberger. Check.

Inaccurate.  Double Check.

Although he’s gotten a lot of love as a possible number one overall pick, no analysis of Wyoming’s Josh Allen fails to mention his 56% career completion percentage.  Some scouts and NFL experts are willing to overlook that, while they praise Allen for the other qualities.

Buffalo Sports Page contributor & Pro Football Weekly Draft Guide author Greg Gabriel is not.

“…there isn’t a quarterback in recent memory who had such a low completion percentage in college and went on to have success in the NFL.”

The inaccuracy has become part of the narrative about Allen.  But is it really true?

To get some inside information on Allen and his accuracy issues, I reached out to someone who has seen him throw every college pass he’s thrown at Wyoming.  Longtime Cowboys radio color analyst Kevin McKinney knows Allen, knows what the coaches asked of him, knows what Allen had around him and knows how the games dictated Allen’s play.

“It’s amusing to hear what everybody’s saying about a guy that most haven’t even seen play.  The thing that makes me cringe the most is that ‘he’s not accurate’ and ‘doesn’t make good decisions.’  That could not be further from the truth.  The guy is a great leader and he won a lot of games for Wyoming that they would not have won had Josh not been at quarterback.  His completion percentage is down because, quite frankly, he was running for his life.  Sometimes it’s hard to make good decisions when you’re on the run,” said McKinney.

“He is a true leader and just a great guy.  We are anxious to have the world know who he is and what he’s all about.”

Loss of Weapons Effected Completions

Following up on the completion percentage issue, McKinney says a loss of three receiving weapons and three starters on the offensive line played a major role in Allen’s stats.

“Lot of drops.  He threw bad balls.  Who doesn’t.  He was victimized on a number of occasions by not having the quality of receivers to throw to.”

Wyoming’s offense asked Allen to throw the ball deep, without a lot of short, easy throws.

“He was asked to throw the ball down the field.  His missed throws were downfield.  He did overthrow balls, and I know he’s been addressing that in his workouts with (QB guru) Jordan Palmer.  At his pro day, Allen was much better with his footwork than he was in his last game with Wyoming.”

McKinney says the Cowboys offense did not run a lot of screens and bubble screen plays, the kind that contribute to a higher completion percentage.  Deep outs and fly patterns were a staple of what Allen was asked to do.

Big Time Arm

McKinney has seen Allen’s arm strength.  He called it an “amazing gift.”  But he also saw Allen back off a bit on the hard throws at his pro day to show his versatility to NFL scouts.  Allen knows those deep ball, 50 to 60 yards throws only happen a few times in an NFL game.

Carson Wentz Connection

Much like the Eagles’ Carson Wentz, Josh Allen comes from a lower level school.  The other connection to Wentz is Wyoming head coach Craig Bohl, who coached Wentz at North Dakota State.

“He compares them very favorably.  They both have big arms.  They’re both able to extend plays with their feet and get out of trouble.  Josh is a lot like Carson in that way,” relates McKinney.

Bohl has said that Allen may need more time to get ready for the NFL than Wentz, who started the first game of his rookie season.

Is the Narrative True?

After listening to McKinney describe what he’s seen from Allen, there is some reason to believe that Allen can improve his completion percentage with better coaching and better weapons.  So while it may be true now, Allen will have a chance to change that.

For me, the completion percentage is still a worry.  Even during his junior year, when he had all those weapons and a veteran offensive line, his completion percentage (56.0%) was LOWER than the senior year that McKinney explained (56.3%).  The old NFL saying is that you can’t teach accuracy, and in the pros, it never gets better.

So any NFL team that takes Allen will have to understand this, and tailor their offense to his strengths, which is his arm strength.

None of the QB prospects are perfect.  Because of his size and arm, Allen will be a top 10 pick.  Narrative or not.


Paul Peck

Paul Peck is sports broadcaster with over 25 years experience in TV and Radio. He served as sports anchor, reporter, and producer at WIVB for 24 years. In that role, he covered all four Buffalo Bills Super Bowls, the Buffalo Sabres in the Stanley Cup Finals, the NCAA Basketball Tournament and the Daytona 500. He has been the Voice of the UB Bulls Football for 17 seasons, in addition to host of Bulls Athletics TV & Radio shows. Peck also served as the sideline reporter for the Buffalo Bills Football Network, host of the bowling show "Beat The Champ" and announces college basketball for ESPN 3 and Time Warner Cable Sports Channel. He has also been the Master of Ceremonies for the Greater Buffalo Sports Hall of Fame, one of the largest sports banquets in WNY.

Paul is also involved in the local business community, having been a financial advisor at AXA Advisors, and is currently the Vice President of Sports Development at VSP Graphics Group.

Leave a Reply